A $1,000 MLS Mistake: Compensation Cannot Hide in Private Remarks

By: T.W. Shortt, CRS®, CRB®, Broker, REALTY WORLD Knox Realty Group LLC

A recent Heart of Kentucky MLS listing contained a short sentence in its private remarks that should get every broker’s attention: 

“Agent is offering a $1,000 selling bonus.” 

Before August 2024, statements offering bonuses to cooperating agents were commonly placed in MLS remarks. That practice has changed. 

Under the MLS policies adopted to implement the National Association of REALTORS® settlement, offers of compensation to buyer brokers or other buyer representatives may no longer be communicated through a REALTOR® multiple listing service. 

That prohibition is not limited to the former commission field. It applies to public remarks, private remarks, showing instructions, photographs, attachments, and other information entered or distributed through the MLS. 

Calling a payment a “selling bonus” instead of a commission does not necessarily change its substance. If the payment is being offered to the agent or brokerage that brings the successful buyer, it likely represents an offer of broker compensation. 

The fact that only real estate professionals can see private remarks also makes no difference. Private remarks remain part of the MLS. 

This does not mean bonuses or offers of buyer-broker compensation have become illegal. Sellers and listing brokers may still negotiate such compensation away from the MLS. They may communicate it through direct telephone calls, emails, individual brokerage websites, and broker-to-broker agreements, subject to applicable laws and the seller’s authorization. 

The settlement changed where compensation can be communicated. It did not prohibit consumers from negotiating how real estate professionals will be paid. 

A seller’s concession is also different from broker compensation. A seller may offer to contribute toward a buyer’s allowable closing expenses. However, a concession published in the MLS cannot be conditioned upon payment to the buyer’s agent or used as disguised compensation. 

The wording matters. “Seller will consider an allowable closing-cost contribution with an acceptable offer” is directed toward the buyer’s transaction expenses. “Agent is offering a $1,000 selling bonus” appears directed toward the real estate professional who produces the sale. 

Buyer brokers must also remember another limitation. A buyer’s broker may not receive compensation exceeding the amount or rate stated in the written buyer’s agreement. If that agreement establishes compensation of $6,000, the brokerage cannot automatically collect an additional $1,000 bonus. Any lawful change would need to be addressed with the buyer and properly documented. 

Does one sentence in private remarks mean the agent committed a federal antitrust violation? Not necessarily. 

The more accurate conclusion is that the statement appears inconsistent with the MLS rule adopted under the settlement. The local MLS—not social media commentators—should investigate the circumstances and determine whether a warning, correction, fine, or other enforcement action is appropriate. 

The lesson for brokers is straightforward: review every listing before it becomes active. Search remarks and attachments for words such as “commission,” “compensation,” “co-op,” “buyer-agent fee,” and “selling bonus.” Older language copied from a previous listing can create a new compliance problem. 

Real estate practices have changed, but many offices still rely on old habits and templates. One sentence copied into the wrong field can expose both the agent and supervising broker to an avoidable MLS violation. 

There is a larger lesson as well. Real estate brokers should compete vigorously on price, service, technology, and value—but they must make those competitive decisions independently. The rules governing compensation have changed, but the fundamental antitrust principle has not:

Competitors must compete.

When it comes to compensation, private remarks are not exempt from the rules. 

Sources: NAR settlement FAQs, NAR consumer guide to compensation, and NAR guidance on compensation and concessions. Heart of Kentucky Association of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service, MLS No. HK2602032, 330 Stonebriar Drive, Elizabethtown, KY 42701, private remarks (updated Aug. 21, 2026) (copy on file with author). 

Before you list, learn your options and potential costs with our Free Kentucky Home Seller Guide.

Thinking about selling your Kentucky home?

Tags: ANALYSIS